Archive for the ‘Western Canada Port Agency (WCPA)’ Category

Ports Review for Hurriers: How to Save the World Today

November 29, 2018

Do you agree with this statement?

Transport Canada should replace the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority with a Western Canada Port Agency that
(1) heeds local governments,
(2) respects the ALR,
(3) treasures ecological diligence,
(4) is transparent and accountable, and
(5) looks first to Prince Rupert—capable, expanding, close to Asia—for port growth.

Yes? Then welcome to Ports Review for Hurriers! You are indispensable, and you will learn fast while quickly saving the world. The ten steps:

1 Download one of the input forms (Word version or PDF)
2 Open the document.
3 Read the directions to the Responder (you).
4 Click on a checkbox to deselect/select an issue.
5 Use the text boxes to add a few details.
6 Save.
7 Click on email link near top of form (to open a blank email).
8 Type something like “Input attached” in the body.
9 Attach your Word/PDF input to the message.
10 Send—by December 3rd.

Thank you!

To celebrate, join the Eurythmics
in “I Saved the World Today
read and take action with the articles below this one.

If you don’t see any, click on the “Natural legacies versus waste” banner. Yes, it would have been useful to read them before doing your input, but that’s “Ports Review for Excellers.”


Cooperating ports—good for Western Canada and all

November 26, 2018

Richmond Council has called on Transport Canada to replace the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority, VFPA or “Port of Vancouver,” with a new Western Canada Port Agency, WCPA. That’s in Richmond’s response to the ministry’s Ports Modernization Review.

WCPA is a new name for a visionary concept associated with former minister David Emerson (over a decade ago) and revived by Joe Peschisolido, a current Richmond MP. For most of a decade, Robin Silvester has been CEO of VFPA. It’s viewed as an oligarchy, and he suits its aims, but it lacks the cooperative-service priority of the WCPA vision.

Along with support for WCPA, Richmond Council’s input includes many concerns and imperatives for consulting with local government, ending conflicts of interest such as VFPA’s “environmental assessments” of itself, and respecting ALR land, not buying it for industrial use. (Details in Nov 26 Richmond Council agenda and in the minutes soon.)

The Ports Modernization Review deadline is Monday, Dec 3. Since it’s urgent, Fraser Voices has put much thought into a fillable input form so you can mold your views if need be and send them in right away. Choose Word version or PDF version.

And if you’re not sure why reform is needed, see this highly informed list of concerns.

The input form includes a simple means (5 seconds) to help MP Joe Peschisolido and his Marine Ports Caucus show the need to add ROUNDTABLES for Ports Review stakeholders after Dec. 3. The intent is that the roundtables will bring together local politicians, environmentalists, business people and other active citizens in dialogue that will help the Transport Canada review to modernize the Western Canada port system. If you may wish to take part, be sure to send in the form with the ROUNDTABLE checkbox checked.

Richmond will send its Ports Modernization Review report to other Metro Vancouver councils, but other councils’ members may receive it too late to use it before Dec 3. If you are a council member in Metro Vancouver or Western Canada, please use the fillable time-saving form to respond, and share it and urge other council members and citizens to do so. If you’re anyone else, please similarly use the form for your valuable input and share it.

Fraser Voices is urging action because we see the unaccountable VFPA (like an oligarchy) as very unfortunate for the health of the Fraser Estuary and the environment. As well, documentation that’s been buried since the Emerson era gives reason to think the WCPA would simultaneously be better for the maritime commerce of Western Canada, with a focus on cooperative service to the vast region, not on growing itself for growth’s sake.


This article has introduced MP Joe Peschisolido of Steveston-Richmond East; Robin Silvester, long-time VFPA CEO with immense power; and former federal minister David Emerson, whose Gateway vision got blinkered by others. You can meet them again in other Fraser Voices articles, nearby on this blog, including a WCPA article and roundtable article. Please do!

The view from here is pretty clear that Robin Silvester and VFPA oligarchy are very adept at growing the VFPA but that the visionary thinking David Emerson showed and Joe Peschisolido respects offers the best prospects in a bigger picture.

A final thought about the input form (in Word version or PDF version): Please just send it off as soon as you finish it, even if you will have more input to the Ports Modernization Review. Since one can send input more then once, there’s no need to wait.

Urge port-review ROUNDTABLES if you care, says MP Joe Peschisolido re Port Agency

November 24, 2018

MP Joe Peschisolido has indicated a need to “blow up” the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority (VFPA). Despite the pyrotechnic glint in his eye, he simply means that VFPA would be easier to replace than to fix. He will enable the overdue Ports Review ROUNDTABLES if stakeholders urge them in their input. The Fraser Voices fillable Input Form makes that simple if one acts fast, since the deadline to email it is Monday, December 3. Download the form now in Word version or PDF version

If local council members, environmental groups and individuals do their part, they can succeed with MP Joe. Along with him, the ROUNDTABLES would likely include Transport Canada leaders and members of the federal Liberal Marine Ports Caucus, which MP Joe chairs. If that process gets the foreseeable results, it will be very good for BC’s ecological health, especially that of the Fraser Estuary and Salish Sea, and it will be good for the Pacific trade of Western Canada.

Why is MP Joe Peschisolido doing this?

He represents the Fraser River Estuary riding of Richmond-Steveston. He has knocked on many doors to hear constituents. He has also listened at his town hall meetings and to Richmond Council. He has heard much about the need for VFPA to change. While doing his job, with his listening and research, MP Joe has become a committed advocate for saving the ecological life of the Fraser from unbridled industrialization, as well as for combining commerce values with environmental ones in general.

In short, there has been longtime disappointment that Vancouver Fraser Port Authority does not collaborate with stakeholders—ports, terminals, all governments, organizations, etc., in BC and beyond, resolving concerns like these ones that the Fraser Voices Association (Richmond-based) and Against Port Expansion (Delta-based) put together. (Click on “concerns . .. ” for thorough, highly informed lists.)

Famously, Robin Silvester, CEO of VFPA, famously stated, “I don’t think we would be bound [by the Agricultural Land Reserve]. As a federal body here at Port Metro Vancouver, we have supremacy,” he said.

With motivation like that, MP Joe’s current commitment is to help the Ports Modernization Review end well and follow up in a further stage. Transport Canada’s consultation period for the Ports Review ends on Monday, December 3. Crucially, though, they haven’t held the many roundtable discussions they promised at the beginning. They appear to have held only one—for port authorities. Joe wants to make up for that.

As Marine Ports Caucus chair, MP Joe has committed to remain very involved in the review for months. In that role, he is also committed to ensuring BC roundtables about the port authorities (especially the Vancouver one) if council members, environmental groups and other individuals send “submissions” before Dec. 3 indicating that they wish to take part in roundtables he arranges.

Prince Rupert is one day closer to Asia than Vancouver—each way! This is one factor in a key proposal to replace the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority with a Western Canada Port Agency.

Download the fillable input form for Transport Canada’s Ports Modernization Review in Word version or PDF version.

Prince Rupert boosted in the proposed Western Canada Port Agency (WCPA)

November 23, 2018

Shorter voyage from Prince Rupert to Asia

Directing new port capacity from Vancouver to Prince Rupert is good for trade with Asia. So is the Western Canada Port Agency (WCPA). Neglected for a decade, the WCPA concept is much needed.

Prince Rupert, with easy access to open ocean, is the deepest natural harbour in North America. It brings Western Canada closer to Asia. It adds port capacity without harming the environment, unlike the proposed Roberts Bank Terminal II (near Vancouver).

To help make WCPA happen, use Fraser Voices’ fillable Input Form in your choice of WWord version or PDF version. and email the input to Transport Canada’s current Ports Modernization Review quickly. Deadline: Monday, Dec. 3. For more resources, use links on the form.

“Blow up the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority,” says MP Joe Peschisolido (Steveston-Richmond East). He means it’s easier to start anew than to untangle VFPA’s ingrained problems. A phrase to express the essence of the solution is Western Canada Port Agency, which might perhaps become a working title.

The name honours the area it serves, Western Canada, instead of a port city. As an Agency, the new entity would still have authority assigned by the federal government, but it would shed the imperious autonomy the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority is known for. In short, the Western Canada Port Agency would replace a self-serving authority with a Canada-serving agency.

This article by the Fraser Voices Association builds on MP Joe’s recent submission to the Ports Modernization Review, which he developed in discussion with Fraser Voices leaders.

Implementing a blue-ribbon panel’s advice to a federal minister, the WCPA would include the ports of both Vancouver and Prince Rupert.We recommend,said the panel,that a single port authority be created to include the existing Vancouver ports plus Prince Rupert. This is the only way to assure complete collaboration of Canada’s West Coast ports. . . .” They went on to add,We recommend that development of container capacity in Prince Rupert be given priority over investment in Vancouver.

On another relevant note, the panel said: “We recommend that a systemic approach be taken to achieve an understanding of port capacity before a conclusion is reached that a particular port must necessarily be physically larger. That could apply to the Western Canada port system as well as each of the ports.

The panel’s report has been only semi-implemented, reportedly due to intra-cabinet politics. It still merits respect, not neglect. In fact, that is implicit in the recent BBCC Analysis of RBT2 report (Oct 1, 2018) from the Boundary Bay Conservation Committee to the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency panel that is reviewing VFPA’s proposed Roberts Bank Terminal 2 (RBT2) in Delta.

Supposedly, the saving grace of Terminal 2 was that it met a necessity for increased Western Canada container capacity uniquely enough to warrant an ecological debacle. However, the Prince Rupert alternative has evidently been under-appreciated because of VFPA’s sleight of hand in downplaying it. Fortunately, the BBCC has debunked the faulty evidence. The Boundary Bay Conservation analysis shows that increased capacity planned for Prince Rupert, along with systemic efficiency, should make Terminal 2 superfluous.

As well, there are long lists of problems that have arisen from the VFPA model of insulated privilege — autonomous but wielding federal power. A number of Metro governments want a port partner that’s more collaborative and accountable. In any case, it’s time to end the Golden Age of the VFPA.

As part of the Western Canada Port Agency, the port of Vancouver would focus on its basic strengths while joining forces with the port of Prince Rupert and others. As providers of port services, they would respond to provincial, municipal, First Nations and community input.

There would also be many associated ports within the Western Canada service area:

  • Port Alberni Port Authority and Nanaimo Port Authority, which are smaller federal marine ports
  • The inland ports in/near Ashcroft, Prince George, Edmonton, Calgary, Regina and Winnipeg
  • Various other federal and non-federal marine and inland ports

It should be a win-win for all: the ports, commerce, the environment and Canada.

Directly and indirectly, the Western Canada Port Agency would involve the whole transport system. It would enable optimal flow of goods from, to and through all parts of Western Canada. That would be very good for the economy and quality of life. It’s related to the Asia-Pacific Gateway and Corridor Initiative, but the modernizing will need to be less Vancouver-centric. One way to think that way would be headquarters in Prince Rupert.

Prince Rupert is one day closer to Asia than Vancouver—each way!

Some other aspects: The Western Canada Port Agency would also ensure that its whole operation fosters both personal safety/wellness and environmental wellness, extending the existing practice of environmental stewardship that is integral to the Port of Prince Rupert. It would not be autocratic, and it would be devised to NOT fall back into the problem behaviours of VFPA. They include concerns like these ones that the Fraser Voices Association (Richmond-based) and Against Port Expansion (Delta-based) put together recently.

To be modern, the Western Canada Port Agency must learn from mistakes, like Apple, which—on the brink of bankruptcy about 22 years ago—finally came to grips with its previous mistake of forcing Steve Jobs out. After mending fences, Apple has done okay.

In this case, the blue-chip panel reported on port modernization over a decade ago—to Minister David Emerson, who soon left politics before implementing the parts cited here. Learning from the missed opportunity can change the world and our little corner of the globe, Western Canada.

Here’s a fillable Ports Modernization fillable Input Form in your choice of Word version or PDF version.

Note: The report to Minister David Emerson was prepared, gratis, by Jeff Burghardt, CEO of Prince Rupert Grain Co.; Arthur Defehr, CEO of Palliser Furniture Ltd., Winnipeg; and Richard Turner, chairman of ICBC. Dated May 28, 2007, the report was public by January 2008. The recommendations are on pages 16–20.

Note: Richmond Council has urged Transport Canada to replace the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority with the Western Canada Port Agency in its input to the Ports Modernization Review.